Skip to main content
FinancePaisa

Personal Loan · Guide

Secured vs unsecured personal loans

Almost every personal loan advertised in India is unsecured. But if you own a fixed deposit, gold or investments, you can borrow against them, usually more cheaply. This guide compares the real cost of each route on the same amount, explains what you risk when you pledge an asset, and shows when the cheaper secured route is not worth it.

By FinancePaisa Editorial Team · Research & editorialUpdated · 5 min read
On this page (9 sections)

The core difference

A secured loan is backed by an asset the lender can claim if you default. An unsecured loan is not. Because the lender's risk is lower on a secured loan, it charges a lower rate, asks fewer questions about your income and credit score, and often disburses the same day. The trade-off is that your asset is locked up until you repay, and in some cases can be sold if its value falls.

Typical rates and speed

  • Unsecured personal loan

    Typical rate (p.a.)
    9.99% – 24%
    Approval speed
    1–5 days (minutes if pre-approved)
    Credit check
    Full
  • Loan against FD

    Typical rate (p.a.)
    1% – 2% above the FD rate
    Approval speed
    Same day
    Credit check
    Minimal
  • Gold loan

    Typical rate (p.a.)
    About 9% – 15%
    Approval speed
    Same day
    Credit check
    Light
  • Loan against mutual funds or shares

    Typical rate (p.a.)
    About 9.5% – 12%
    Approval speed
    1–2 days, often online
    Credit check
    Light

Worked example: ₹2 lakh for 12 months

Here is what the same ₹2 lakh, repaid in 12 EMIs, costs on each route. The rates and fees are illustrative mid-market figures, not quotes; plug your own offers into the EMI calculator.
  • Unsecured personal loan

    Rate
    13%
    EMI
    ₹17,863
    Interest
    ₹14,361
    Fee + GST
    ₹4,720
    Total cost
    ₹19,081
  • Loan against FD (FD at 7%, loan at FD + 1.5%)

    Rate
    8.5%
    EMI
    ₹17,444
    Interest
    ₹9,327
    Fee + GST
    ₹0
    Total cost
    ₹9,327
  • Gold loan

    Rate
    10%
    EMI
    ₹17,583
    Interest
    ₹10,998
    Fee + GST
    ₹1,180
    Total cost
    ₹12,178
  • Loan against mutual funds

    Rate
    10.5%
    EMI
    ₹17,630
    Interest
    ₹11,557
    Fee + GST
    ₹1,180
    Total cost
    ₹12,737

What the example shows

The loan against an FD costs about ₹9,754 less than the unsecured loan over a year, mostly because there is no 2% processing fee and the rate is several points lower. On a smaller amount or a shorter period the gap shrinks to a few thousand rupees, and the convenience of not locking up an asset may be worth more than the saving. One more comparison matters for FDs: breaking the deposit instead. If your FD earns 7% and the loan against it costs 8.5%, the loan's real cost is only the 1.5% gap, and you keep the deposit running. Breaking it early usually means a lower interest rate for the period held plus a penalty, so compare both before deciding.

Advertisement

What you risk with each secured route

  • Fixed deposit: the bank can adjust the FD against the loan if you stop paying. Low risk, but the FD is locked until you repay.
  • Gold: lenders lend only part of the gold's value (RBI caps the loan-to-value at 85% for small consumption loans up to ₹2.5 lakh, lower for larger loans). If gold prices fall, you may be asked to repay part of the loan or add gold; if you default, the lender can auction the gold after giving notice.
  • Mutual funds and shares: lenders typically lend about half the value of equity holdings and more against debt funds. A market fall can trigger a margin call with only a few days to pay, and unpaid calls lead to your units being sold at the low price.
  • Unsecured loan: nothing is pledged, but a default damages your credit score for years and leads to recovery action.

When the secured route makes sense

  • You already own an asset you do not want to sell, such as an FD, gold or long-term investments.
  • The amount is large enough that a few percentage points saves real money.
  • Your credit score or income would only get you a high unsecured rate, or none at all.
  • You need the money today, and a pre-approved unsecured offer is not available.

When unsecured is the better choice

If the loan is small relative to your income, your credit score is strong and you can repay in one to three years, an unsecured personal loan is usually the cleaner choice. You keep your FD as an emergency reserve, avoid margin calls, and there are no release formalities when you close. It is also the only choice when the asset is someone else's or is already pledged.

Frequently asked questions

Can I break my FD instead of taking a loan against it?

You can, but you usually earn a lower rate for the period the FD was held and may pay a premature-withdrawal penalty. Compare that loss with the interest gap on a loan against the FD, which is typically only 1-2% a year.

Is a gold loan risky?

The main risk is a sharp fall in gold prices, which can lead to a demand to repay part of the loan or add gold. Borrowing well below the maximum loan-to-value and keeping the tenure short keeps that risk small.

Which is easier to prepay?

Secured loans are generally easier: many loans against FDs, gold and securities can be closed at any time without a charge. Unsecured personal loans are usually fixed-rate and can carry a foreclosure charge, often 2-4% of the outstanding, sometimes falling to nil after a set number of EMIs. Check the Key Facts Statement.

Does a secured loan affect my credit score?

Yes. Secured loans are reported to the credit bureaus like any other loan, and paying on time improves your history. A healthy mix of secured and unsecured credit is viewed positively.

Sources & references

Rates, fees, eligibility, and product terms cited on this page reflect the sources above at the time of publication and may have changed since. Always verify directly with the lender or regulator.

Related pages